Roaring Fork Valley · Colorado · Philanthropy Consulting
Strategic philanthropy counsel for transformational gifts, major gifts, planned giving, and board engagement — and private foundation advisory for families ready to give with intention. Rooted in the Roaring Fork Valley, reaching across the nation.
“Transformational giving begins with a relationship built on trust, shared values, and a clear vision for impact — and the expertise to make it happen.”
Lindsay Aroesty — Roaring Fork Philanthropy
What We Do
Whether you’re a nonprofit seeking transformational gifts or a private family foundation clarifying your legacy — Roaring Fork Philanthropy delivers customized strategy built on 20+ years of frontline experience.
Design and implement planned giving programs that build lasting pipelines of estate commitments — from donor cultivation to gift closure, bequest societies, legacy recognition, and professional advisor engagement.
Strategic counsel on identifying, cultivating, and closing transformational gifts from six to eight figures. A proven track record securing gifts from $10M to $40M, guiding your team through every step.
Strengthen your board’s philanthropic culture through training, coaching, and facilitation. Help board members understand their role in fundraising and serve as confident ambassadors for your mission.
Audit and redesign your fundraising infrastructure — from CRM strategy and prospect management to donor communications — building systems that consistently deliver results year over year.
Build and activate referral relationships with estate attorneys, financial advisors, and CPAs to create a steady flow of planned and major gift referrals that expand your reach into new donor communities.
About Lindsay
Lindsay Aroesty is a nationally recognized philanthropy executive with more than 20 years of leadership at The Pittsburgh Foundation — one of the nation’s largest community foundations with $1.5 billion in assets.
As Vice President of Development & Donor Services, Lindsay led a team of 16 professionals and achieved $102 million raised in her final year — the single largest fundraising year in the Foundation’s history. She is, above all, a closer: someone who builds the relationship, earns the trust, and knows exactly when and how to make the ask.
As leader of the Amelia Group — a national cohort of chief philanthropy officers at the country’s largest community foundations — Lindsay developed deep expertise in how community foundations across the nation collaborate to maximize philanthropic impact. Now based in the Roaring Fork Valley, she brings that national perspective and executive-level expertise to organizations ready to elevate their own philanthropic impact.
Our Approach
Transformational giving is built on trust. We take time to understand your donors, your community, and your organization’s authentic identity before crafting any strategy.
Big-picture national expertise with the intimacy of the Roaring Fork Valley — a community long known for attracting visionary philanthropists and bold ideas.
Like the rivers that define this valley, great philanthropy programs run year-round. We build durable systems — not one-time campaigns — that generate sustained momentum.
We work alongside your staff and leadership — not above them. Our goal is to leave your organization stronger and more confident in its own fundraising voice.
Every engagement is guided by values: collaboration, racial justice, accountability, and trust. Philanthropy done well is a powerful tool for community-wide equity and lasting change.
The gifts that change organizations — and communities — require courage. We help you make the ask, tell the story, and hold the vision until it becomes reality.
Relationships matter. Strategy matters. But at the end of the day, results are what count. Lindsay has closed gifts from $10M to $40M and brings that same relentless, donor-centered focus to every engagement — because inspiration without execution is just a good conversation.
On the National Stage
Lindsay is a sought-after national conference speaker on fundraising strategy, capital campaign models, and planned giving — bringing real-world insight from one of the nation’s largest community foundations to stages across the country.
Get in Touch
Whether you’re ready to launch a campaign, strengthen your planned giving program, or simply explore what’s possible — I’d love to connect.
About Lindsay Aroesty
A fundraiser, a strategist, a ski racer, a marathoner, a mother — someone who shows up fully for every person, every cause, every challenge.
“I’ve spent 20+ years closing transformational gifts, building programs from the ground up, and partnering with families to make their philanthropy matter. I bring that same commitment — and the credentials to back it up — to every client I work with.”
The Story
Lindsay Aroesty didn’t stumble into philanthropy — she ran toward it. After graduating cum laude from Colby College, she launched her career at The Taft School, contributing to a $150 million capital campaign while conducting 100+ annual visits with high-net-worth alumni.
In 2010, she joined The Pittsburgh Foundation and never looked back. Over 15 years she rose through four roles to become Vice President of Development & Donor Services, leading a team of 16 across $1.5 billion in assets and 3,000 component funds.
Her final year was the punctuation mark on a remarkable career: $102 million raised — the single largest fundraising year in the Foundation’s history. She stewarded the 2nd and 3rd largest estate gifts ever received ($37.1M and $34M) and built a $300M+ planned giving pipeline. The through-line across all of it: she knows how to close. From the first conversation to the signed gift agreement, Lindsay brings a relentless, donor-centered focus to getting transformational gifts across the finish line.
Now Lindsay has brought her talents home to the Roaring Fork Valley, launching Roaring Fork Philanthropy, LLC — registered with the Colorado Secretary of State — to help organizations reach their own transformational moments.
Career
🌐 National Leadership
Lindsay led the Amelia Group — an exclusive national cohort of chief philanthropy officers representing the largest community foundations across the United States. This peer network convened the country’s top philanthropy executives to share best practices, tackle sector-wide challenges, and develop strategies for cross-community collaboration and collective impact.
Through the Amelia Group, Lindsay built deep fluency in how community foundations in different cities and regions can partner together to maximize impact for nonprofits, raise critical dollars for community needs, and move philanthropy forward as a field. It’s the kind of national perspective that most consultants simply don’t have — and that Lindsay brings to every client engagement.
Whether your organization is navigating a local challenge or a national trend, Lindsay has sat at the table where those conversations happen at the highest level.
The Amelia Group — Gulf Coast Community Foundation, Sarasota 2023
Education
Certifications & Recognition
Beyond the Work
Outside of work, Lindsay is most at home in the mountains. A lifelong skier and USSS certified ski coach, she has two kids who race — and she’s often the one on the hill with them. She’s also run five marathons and plays tennis and golf, because one pursuit is never quite enough.
At the center of it all is her family — full of people she loves, places that restore her, and adventures that remind her what it means to push past limits. That fullness is what makes her counsel so grounded. Read her HVRC coaching bio →
The Aroesty family, Pittsburgh
🏓 On the Mountain
Lindsay began racing in 1988 with the Okemo Mountain Race Team and went on to captain The Taft School’s Prep Alpine Team, earning MVP honors in 1999. She spent over two decades as a ski instructor at Sugarloaf USA before earning her USSA Level 1 certification in 2022.
Today she coaches with the Hidden Valley Race Club — where two of her own children race. She brings to every gate the same patience, precision, and belief in the athlete that she brings to every donor relationship.
Read Her HVRC Coaching Bio →Whether your organization is at the beginning of a campaign or the cusp of something transformational — let’s talk.